The Thought Instigator
I’m happy with “Happy Holidays.”
I’m also happy with “Merry Christmas.” With “Happy Hannukah.” And how about, “Have a cool yule?”
Sound conflicting, in this day of judgmental disdain for political correctness? Well, a couple things…
I’m okay with expressions of joy, of guiltless communication of our boundless spirit and appreciation of our celebrations.
I’m not okay, however, with others’ rules that dictate why we should or shouldn’t express ourselves as we see fit as opposed to how they see fit.
How many times have we heard: “Hey, it’s merry Christmas! It’s not happy holidays! That’s politically correct, and I won’t be politically correct!” In other words, the real holiday is Christmas. The others are irrelevant. So don’t make them something more than irrelevant by lumping them in with Christmas. At least, that seems to be the logic.
Um, memo. There’s a bunch of holidays that occur during “the holidays.” Holidays, plural. And, to those who celebrate them, they’re meaningful. They’re relevant. Even as much as Christmas!

What they are, and aren’t
Okay, a quick primer. (And apologies for leaving anything/anyone out; I’m bound to miss something!)
A lot of people think “The Holidays” start with Thanksgiving and end with New Year’s Day. Others will tag on the Chinese New Year, but to my small mind, that’s so next year. Even New Year’s is next year, except that it’s attached to New Year’s Eve (my anniversary, by the way), so it qualifies in my book as a holidays bookend.
I get the Thanksgiving aspect of “The Holidays,” although this period smacks of December to me. If we’re going to agree for the moment – and I didn’t hear anyone object – to Thanksgiving being a cast member of “The Holidays,” then I’ll listen to the argument that Diwali should be too. Diwali is that cool Hindu holiday celebrating life, and good over evil. It can take place in October or November, depending on the year’s lunisolar calendar placement. The Hindu calendar follows the moon and is 354 days long, so every three years they toss in a month or so. So you can see why it falls in October or November. It was in late October this year.
I said I’d listen to the argument, but I’m not buying into it being among the holidays meant when we say “Happy Holidays!” October? No. For that matter, I think Thanksgiving stands on its own as a superb holiday – I don’t think “the holidays” when Thanksgiving pops up. Finishing the last bowl of turkey soup feels like a door opener to “The Holidays.” No, I’m ducking back behind my thought that “The Holidays” take place in December. And New Year’s. What ev!
The lineup
1. Okay, so we have Hanukkah. According to the interesting website “Her Campus” (a medium designed for women in college, new to me), found here: https://www.hercampus.com/school/minnesota/6-holidays-holiday-season-besides-christmas, “Hanukkah is a Jewish holiday that’s celebrated for eight days and nights, beginning on the 25th day of the Jewish month of Kislev. The Jewish calendar is based on the lunar cycle, so Hanukkah can fall anywhere from November 28th to December 26th. … People celebrate Hanukkah by lighting their menorahs, spinning dreidels and eating delicious foods!”
I can testify that dreidel spinning is fun, from my one experience spinning them.
Hanukkah certainly qualifies as a holiday season holiday. It runs from December 18 to December 26 this year.
2. Then there’s Kwanzaa. “In the United States, roughly five million people celebrate Kwanzaa each year! Kwanzaa is a seven day holiday that celebrates African culture. It begins on December 26th and ends on January 1st. On the sixth day of Kwanzaa (my anniversary…hint, hint), there’s a Kwanzaa Karamu, which is a big feast. Gifts of Kuumba (creativity) are given to loved ones. Kwanzaa’s also celebrated through lighting the Kinara, performing and listening to traditional music and discussing African principles and history.” Her Campus
Five million people are not the definition of irrelevant.
3. I think we’re on a roll! Now, some would say winter solstice falls into the holiday season definition. “For Pagans, December means the holiday of Yule is coming! It falls on December 21st, which marks the winter solstice; which is the shortest day and longest night of the year. The winter solstice celebrates the rebirth of the sun, because days get longer from then on out.” More Her Campus
I know pagans who celebrate winter solstice, so that’s on the list.
4. Next on my list is Los Posados. “From December 16th through December 24th, Las Posadas is celebrated by some Hispanic families in the United States. It’s a nine-day celebration before Christmas, beginning with a procession with candles, songs and sometimes even people playing the parts of Mary and Joseph who lead the parade. Every night of Las Posadas is celebrated with gifts, piñatas, song, parties, tamales and prayer.” Yup, Her Campus
Okay, I’m buyin’ it.
5. And, of course, Christmas. I do celebrate Christmas.
6. And, finally, New Year’s (and my anniversary – I definitely celebrate that :).
And for the truly open-minded, if you want, toss in Festivus – Festivus for the Rest of Us – on December 23. Thank you crazy man Jerry Stiller for espousing it on “Seinfeld!”
Political correctness?
You know, saying happy holidays probably is being politically correct. For that matter, I don’t see anything wrong with expressing sentiment that is inclusive of other cultures, beyond my limited scope of being Christmas-minded. Fact is, I am Christmas-minded. I don’t observe Hannukah, Kwanzaa, winter solstice, or Los Posados. But I’m aware that others do, and that these traditions fall during “The Holidays.”
I’m grateful to realize that. For a long time I didn’t. And then people started saying happy holidays. Holidays, plural. Opened my eyes. And my mind. Which is a good thing. Therefore, my simple logic holds, there’s nothing wrong with saying happy holidays. Nor is there saying merry Christmas. But there is something weird telling others what’s okay to say and what isn’t – judge, judge.
What do you think?
How about you? What’s your favorite holiday season greeting? What do you like, not like, etc.? Why, for polite conversation’s sake? It’s okay to have an opinion about it. No harm believing in something – unless, of course, you’re evil. I’m going to be welcoming of all cultures celebrating holidays during this season of the calendar. I’m going to say happy holidays when it feels appropriate, or merry Christmas, or happy Hannukah, or whatever works in the moment. And not worry about it.
Don’t want to say happy holidays? Then don’t; I don’t care. Just don’t cast a crappy light on me for choosing to be polite and accepting of others.
Happy holidays!